The four-part feedback structure
| Part | What it holds | Example sentence |
|---|---|---|
| Situation | When and where it happened | In Tuesday's planning call, when we got to the delivery dates, |
| Behaviour | What you observed, without interpretation | you said the estimate was wrong before I had finished the numbers. |
| Effect | What happened for you or the work | I lost the thread and we left the date unresolved. |
| Request | What you would like next time, and an offer | Could you flag your concern after I finish, and I will bring the numbers first? |
The six role-play scenarios
| Scenario | The situation | What the pair practises |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Partial information | A project update reached the planning meeting without the figures another team was still preparing. The presenter knew the numbers were incomplete. | Naming what is not ready yet, and agreeing how to hand over partial information sooner. |
| 2. The interruption | During a planning call a colleague interrupted twice while a decision was being explained. The person speaking wanted to flag a deadline. | Describing the interruption without judging intent, and asking for the deadline to be heard in turn. |
| 3. The missing owner | A handover document omitted a named owner because both people assumed a previous conversation had settled it. | Saying what was missing from the document, and agreeing where ownership will be recorded next time. |
| 4. Late review comments | Review comments on a shared document arrived after the work had been sent on. The reviewer had been on leave without cover. | Raising the timing as a process question rather than a personal one, and proposing a cover arrangement. |
| 5. The decision that moved | A decision recorded in the weekly note changed after a side conversation. Two people had already started work on the earlier version. | Saying what you understood, checking it, and asking where a change will be recorded. |
| 6. Asking for help late | A colleague asked for help twenty minutes before a deadline that had been known for a week. | Saying what the late request cost, and agreeing a signal for asking earlier. |
Observer sheet
| What to record | What good looks like | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Exact words for the situation | A time and place, not a general pattern | |
| Behaviour described without interpretation | What was seen or heard, no motive attached | |
| Effect stated in the first person | I could not finish the point, rather than you do not listen | |
| The request | Specific, doable next time, with an offer | |
| What the speaker checked | A question that invited the other perspective | |
| What the listener could commit to | A concrete change, or an honest limit | |
| What both people accepted as the next step | One step, one owner, one date |
What you'll leave with
Participants practise describing an observation, checking the other person’s view and agreeing a practical next step.
Before the session
- Create trios with speaker, receiver and observer roles. Use fictional examples to avoid turning practice into a live performance discussion.
- Explain that this is a practice activity, not an assessment of competence. Participants can observe or write instead of role-playing.
- Share all six scenarios and the observer sheet in advance. Prepare a private way for participants to raise a concern and a clear route back from breakout rooms.
The run of show
Introduce the practice
Explain the four moves: describe a specific event, explain its effect, ask for the other person’s perspective, and agree a next step. Say: “We are practising curiosity and clarity. You do not need a perfect script.” Avoid presenting this as a validated assessment or a guaranteed conflict-resolution method.
Demonstrate and notice
Model: “In yesterday’s handover, the due date was missing. I could not tell which request to start first. What was happening from your side?” The receiver explains a competing constraint. Together agree a small change. Ask what made the opening specific and where the speaker left room for correction.
Practise in three rounds
Each eight-minute round has one minute to prepare, four minutes to talk and three minutes for reflection. Rotate roles so everyone has one turn as speaker, receiver and observer. Use a different fictional scenario each time. Observers describe words or actions they noticed rather than rating personalities.
Compare learning
Return to the main room. Invite patterns, not details about another participant. Ask which question opened the conversation and where an assumption crept in. List helpful wording. Discuss how the speaker could check the accuracy of an observation before giving feedback.
Draft a transfer plan
Individually choose a low-stakes future conversation. Write the observation, effect and opening question. Do not include private names or sensitive details in the shared document. Identify what information you would need to check before the real conversation.
Close and make room for questions
Invite each person to share one phrase they want to practise, or pass. Remind the group that serious misconduct or an unsafe power relationship needs a suitable organisational process, not simply a better feedback sentence.
Participant worksheet
Copy this table into a document, or print the worksheet from the bundle. Share only what you choose.
| Item | specific event | effect | question | proposed next step |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scenario A | A project update arrived after the planning meeting. The receiver was waiting for figures from another team. Agree how to communicate partial information sooner. | |||
| Scenario B | A colleague interrupted twice during a planning call. The receiver thought the decision had already been made and wanted to flag a deadline. Explore both perspectives. | |||
| Scenario C | A handover document omitted a named owner. The receiver assumed ownership was clear from a previous chat. Agree where ownership will be recorded. | |||
| Speaker notes | specific event | effect | question | proposed next step |
| Receiver notes | your perspective | constraint | what you can commit to | |
| Observer notes | exact words that described an event | question that invited another perspective | ||
| Observer notes | assumption to check | next step both people accepted | ||
| Personal transfer plan | what to verify | opening sentence | when to practise |
Debrief questions
- Which wording described behaviour without labelling the person?
- Where did asking a question change your understanding?
- Was the next step explicit and feasible for both people?
Adapt it for your group
- With four participants, use two pairs and replace the observer with a written self-reflection after each round.
- For multilingual groups, allow preparation in a preferred language and extra thinking time. Keep the scenario details simple.
- If role-play feels uncomfortable, write two possible openings and discuss their likely effects instead.
After the session
Invite participants to reflect privately after a low-stakes real conversation: what did I check, what did I learn, and what was agreed? Do not request recordings or confidential details as evidence.
Questions people ask
How do I run feedback role-play without it feeling awkward?
Use fictional scenarios, keep rounds to eight minutes, and put everyone in a trio so one person always observes. Nobody practises a real grievance about somebody in the room.
How many practice rounds fit in an hour?
Three rounds of eight minutes with a short debrief after each. The run of show on this page uses 24 minutes for the three rounds inside a 60-minute session.
What should the observer do?
Write down exact words, the question the speaker asked, and the next step both people accepted. Observers report what they saw, not what they thought the speaker meant.
Do these exercises use real workplace conflicts?
No. All six scenarios are invented for practice. Use the structures with a real situation only in private, with the person concerned, and with support if the topic is sensitive.
How to use the files
Print the PDF, edit the Word file in Word or Google Docs, or open the CSV or XLSX in a spreadsheet. Open files need no email.
Can I use this with paying clients?
Yes. Use and adapt this original Superglue kit in your own training, including paid client sessions. Please share this page rather than redistributing the unmodified kit. Read the full usage terms.